Maryland’s Push To Change Its Negligence Standard: Where Comparative Fault Reform Stands Today

Imagine being struck by a speeding driver, only to learn you cannot recover a dollar because an insurer says you stepped off the curb a moment too soon. In Maryland, that result is legally possible. The state is one of only four states, along with the District of Columbia, that still follow contributory negligence. Our Maryland personal injury attorneys follow every attempt to change the rule, and this post tracks where reform stands as of October 2026.
How Contributory Negligence Works Today
Under contributory negligence, an injured person’s own fault, however slight, can bar recovery entirely, according to the Maryland Department of Legislative Services. Roughly 45 states take the opposite approach, known as comparative fault, which reduces compensation by the injured person’s share of blame instead of eliminating it.
That gap matters in real cases. Insurers look for any argument that a victim shared responsibility, because even a small percentage can end a claim.
What the 2026 Bill Would Have Changed
House Bill 466 was introduced in the 2026 General Assembly session and proposed a limited form of reform. Its main features were:
- A comparative negligence standard limited to crashes involving a “vulnerable individual,” a category aimed at people outside a vehicle’s protective shell, such as pedestrians and bicyclists.
- A bar on recovery only if the injured person’s negligence was greater than the combined negligence of all defendants.
- Damages reduced in proportion to the injured person’s share of fault.
- Application only to causes of action arising on or after October 1, 2026.
Drivers and passengers in ordinary car crashes would not have been covered.
Where the Bill Stands Now
The House Judiciary Committee heard the bill on February 11, 2026. On March 19, 2026, it was referred to interim study, and the Maryland Association of Counties reports that it did not pass during the 2026 session.
Reform has faced resistance. The bill’s fiscal and policy note flags the potential for added costs to State and local governments from changes to tort liability.
Will the Courts Act First?
Not so far. In a September 2025 opinion, the Appellate Court of Maryland reaffirmed that contributory negligence remains the law and that any change must come from the Supreme Court of Maryland or the General Assembly.
Reform proposals could return when the 2027 session convenes in January, and we will update this post as developments occur.
Injured in Maryland? Do Not Assume You Have No Claim
Until the law changes, the current rule applies to your case. Whether an insurer blames you for 1 percent or 50 percent of a crash, how fault is investigated and documented from day one can shape the outcome.
At Berman Sobin Gross LLP, our Maryland personal injury lawyers build every case with contributory negligence defenses in mind. If an insurer has suggested that you share blame for your injuries, call us before you respond. Request a consultation today.
Sources:
https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026RS/fnotes/bil_0006/hb0466.pdf https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/Legislation/Details/hb0466?ys=2026RS https://www.courts.state.md.us/sites/default/files/unreported-opinions/2053s24.pdf
